Saturday, March 12, 2011

Airport Scanners - only useful during "busy times"?

USA Today is reporting that a new study is being conducted on the "backscatter" scanners.  (there are 2 types of scanners at airports - this is the one that emits small amts of ionizing radiation.  The other is a millimeter wave scanner and doesn't involve radiation)

Here's a confidence builder - apparently some maintenance records indicated radiation was 10 times higher than expected on several machines (19 out of 40 tested).  Rapiscan, the company that makes the backscatter machines, says their employees who tested the machines were "confused" about the forms they had to fill out, so there weren't really any radiation issues - it was simply "math mistakes".  (note:  there are 247 of these scanners at 38 different airports)

I remain perplexed about airport scanners.  At a cost of $170,000 each, and claims they detect more than the traditional metal detectors, one would think they would be used after they are installed.  Yet this week, I once again encountered a scanner sitting idle at an airport (Houston).  It wasn't a busy time at security - no long lines.  One scanner was in use, the second was not - instead, they were having people go through a metal detector that was sitting next to the scanner.  Ironically, there was a large sign as you entered the security area stating they were using "state of the art" scanning devices.  I forget the exact statement but something to do with safer air travel.

This is a view of the security area after you have gone through the process.  The larger, cylindrical scanner on the right is apparently one of the millimeter wave scanners (grayish white).  This one wasn't in service.  Instead, they were having people go through a metal detector which you can see behind and  just to the left of the scanner. 
In case you're wondering why this issue bugs me, I have a piece of titanium in my leg and if I go through a scanner I avoid the waiting around for a female TSA agent to pat me down and the debate that invariably ensues when they try to stack the bin with my coat, shoes and zip lock bag of liquids on top of the bin that contains my laptop!  When I have plenty of time to get through security, I'll sometimes avoid the backscatter scanners (I admit I don't trust the government's radiation exposure studies). 

A couple of scanner facts I've read in other postings:
-the backscatter, radiation emitting scanners are blue and have 2 walls
-the non-radiation scanners are greyish white (see photo above)
-reports I've read indicate the cost for operating scanners in the U.S. over a 10 year period is $6,000,000,000

If scanners are better at detecting potential explosive devices, guns etc, why aren't they being used?

Friday, March 4, 2011

BNA - Nashville airport - haven for scanning equipment

Last week I shared information about finding scanners at airports and commented that not all airports have them.  Yesterday, I went through security at the Nashville, TN airport and was surprised to see several scanners  - and guess what?   NOT ONE OF THEM WAS OPERATIONAL!!

There had to be 20+ TSA agents attending the security area, so I figure it wasn't an issue of staffing.  When I asked one of the TSA agents why none of the scanners were working he said "I'm not sure - maybe they shut them down because this isn't our busy time".

I have no idea if it costs more money to operate a scanner vs. a metal detector but if each scanner costs $170,000, that's almost $700,000 of equipment sitting idle.  I'd also assume it requires more manpower to conduct all the "patdowns" that were being done since the scanners weren't working.

Our tax dollars at work (or not at work). 

Side note:  I'm curious why Nashville has so many scanners and why they search cars before you are allowed to park in the parking garage (found that out when returning a rental car). 

Here's the government's website if you want to check out scanner availability before you fly.  There's a list of airports    http://www.tsa.gov/

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Mike Sampayo and Majalisa Diaz - Thank you for Serving our Country!


O'Hare airport
March 4, 2011

Majalisa Diez - Army
Serving our country for 9 years.
Specialty - logistics
hometown - Hutchinson, MN

Mike Sampayo
Serving our country for 5 years
Specialty - motorpool
hometown - Eugene, OR

Thank you for serving our country and keeping us safe!